When is a Settlement Agreement Used?

​

Settlement agreements are frequently used where there is:

• Redundancy.

• Performance or capability concerns.

• Workplace grievances.

• Disciplinary issues.

• Allegations of discrimination.

• Personality conflicts.

• Breakdown in the employment relationship.

• Potential Employment Tribunal claims.

​

They are often an effective alternative to lengthy disciplinary procedures or tribunal litigation because they provide certainty, reduce legal costs and allow both parties to move forward more quickly.

​

Who Can Enter Into a Settlement Agreement?

​

Depending on the type of legal claim involved, settlement agreements may be entered into by:

​

• Employees.

• Former employees.

• Workers.

• Former workers.

• Job applicants.

​

Certain claims, such as unfair dismissal, can only be brought by employees. Other claims, including discrimination, may also be available to workers and applicants. The agreement should therefore reflect the individual's employment status and the claims being settled.

​

What Makes a Settlement Agreement Legally Valid?

​

For a settlement agreement to be enforceable in England and Wales, it must:

​

• Be in writing.

• Relate to specific legal complaints or claims.

• Identify the legal claims being waived.

• Confirm that statutory requirements have been met.

• Be signed after the employee has received advice from an independent adviser.

• Identify the independent adviser, who must hold appropriate professional insurance.

​

A general statement attempting to settle "all possible claims" without identifying them will usually not satisfy the statutory requirements.

​

Why Do Employers Offer Settlement Agreements?

​

Employers commonly offer settlement agreements because they:

​

• Avoid the uncertainty of Employment Tribunal proceedings.

• Reduce legal costs.

• Protect confidential business information.

• Resolve workplace disputes quickly.

• Agree an exit on mutually acceptable terms.

• Reduce disruption to the business.

​

However, settlement agreements should not replace good management practices. Employers should still consider whether performance management, grievance procedures or mediation could resolve the issue more appropriately.

​

Can an Employee Suggest a Settlement Agreement?

​

Yes.

​

Many people assume only employers can initiate settlement discussions, but employees can also propose a settlement agreement where they believe the employment relationship has irretrievably broken down.

​

This often happens where:

​

• Trust and confidence have been lost.

• Workplace relationships have deteriorated.

• There is an ongoing grievance.

• Both parties recognise that leaving on agreed terms is preferable to litigation.

​

What Does a Settlement Agreement Usually Include?

​

Although every agreement is different, most contain:

​

• Compensation payment.

• Notice pay.

• Payment for accrued but unused holiday.

• Bonus or commission payments (where applicable).

• Pension arrangements.

• Agreed termination date.

• Agreed employment reference.

• Return of company property.

• Confidentiality obligations.

• Waiver of specified Employment Tribunal claims.

​

The precise wording is important because once signed, the agreement is legally binding.

​

How Much Compensation Should You Receive?

​

There is no fixed settlement agreement calculator or standard formula.

​

The value depends upon factors including:

​

• Strength of any legal claims.

• Potential tribunal compensation.

• Length of employment.

• Salary and benefits.

• Likelihood of obtaining new employment.

• Whether discrimination or whistleblowing allegations exist.

• Notice entitlement.

• Redundancy payments.

• Outstanding contractual payments.

​

The purpose of negotiation is to reach a figure that reflects the legal risks faced by both parties.

​

Are Settlement Agreement Payments Taxable?

​

One of the most common questions concerns tax.

​

Different parts of a settlement payment are taxed differently.

​

Generally:

​

Usually taxable

• Salary.

• Holiday pay.

• Bonuses.

• Commission.

• Payment in lieu of notice (PILON).

​

Often tax-free (subject to the relevant tax rules)

​

• The first £30,000 of qualifying compensation for loss of employment.

• Statutory redundancy payments.

​

Because tax treatment varies depending on the circumstances, professional legal and tax advice should always be obtained before signing.

​

Do You Need Independent Legal Advice?

​

Yes.

​

Independent legal advice is a legal requirement.

​

Your adviser will explain:

​

• The claims you are giving up.

• Whether the compensation is reasonable.

• The tax implications.

• The confidentiality provisions.

• Restrictive covenants.

• The practical consequences of signing.

​

Without independent legal advice from a qualified adviser, the agreement will generally not be legally effective.

​

Who Pays the Legal Fees?

​

In most cases, employers contribute towards the employee's legal costs.

​

Many employers offer a fixed contribution, allowing the employee to obtain independent advice without paying personally.

​

If additional negotiations are required, further legal costs may arise depending on the complexity of the matter.

​

How Long Do You Have to Consider a Settlement Agreement?

​

There is no absolute statutory deadline.

​

However, the ACAS Code of Practice recommends allowing employees at least 10 calendar days to consider a written settlement agreement and obtain legal advice.

​

Employees should never feel pressured into signing immediately.

​

Are Settlement Discussions Confidential?

​

Usually, yes.

​

Settlement negotiations are often protected by:

​

• The "without prejudice" rule.

• Section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996 (for qualifying pre-termination negotiations).

​

This protection encourages open discussions without fear that negotiations will later be used in tribunal proceedings.

​

However, confidentiality is not unlimited. Protection may be lost where there has been discrimination, intimidation, harassment, fraud, blackmail or other improper behaviour.

​

What is a Confidentiality Clause?

​

Most settlement agreements include a confidentiality clause (sometimes referred to as a non-disclosure agreement or NDA).

​

It may require the parties to keep confidential:

​

• The existence of the agreement.

• The settlement amount.

• The circumstances surrounding the dispute.

​

Importantly, confidentiality clauses cannot prevent someone from:

​

• Reporting criminal conduct.

• Whistleblowing.

• Cooperating with regulatory authorities.

• Obtaining legal advice.

​

These protections remain in place regardless of any confidentiality wording.

​

What Happens if a Settlement Agreement is Breached?

​

A settlement agreement is a contract.

​

If either party fails to comply—for example, an employer fails to pay compensation or an employee breaches confidentiality—the other party may bring a breach of contract claim before the County Court in England and Wales.

​

Settlement Agreement or Employment Tribunal?

​

A settlement agreement is often preferable where both parties want certainty.

​

An Employment Tribunal may still be appropriate where:

​

• The employer refuses to negotiate fairly.

• Serious discrimination has occurred.

• The proposed compensation is inadequate.

• Important legal principles need determining.

• Settlement discussions have involved improper behaviour.

​

Every case should be assessed on its own facts before deciding whether settlement or litigation offers the better outcome.

​

Frequently Asked Questions

​

What is an employment settlement agreement?

​

A legally binding agreement that resolves an employment dispute, usually in exchange for compensation and the employee agreeing not to pursue specified legal claims.

​

Is a settlement agreement legally binding?

​

Yes. Once properly signed and independent legal advice has been obtained, it is legally enforceable.

​

Do I need a solicitor to review my settlement agreement?

​

Yes. Independent legal advice is a statutory requirement before the agreement becomes legally valid.

​

How much should I receive under a settlement agreement?

​

There is no standard amount. Compensation depends on your contractual rights, potential legal claims, financial losses and the strength of your negotiating position.

​

Is a settlement agreement taxable?

​

Some elements are taxable, while qualifying compensation for loss of employment may benefit from favourable tax treatment, including the potential £30,000 exemption.

​​

Can I negotiate a settlement agreement?

​

Yes. The initial offer is rarely the final offer. Compensation, references, notice pay, legal fees, restrictive covenants and confidentiality provisions can all be negotiated.

​

Can I refuse to sign a settlement agreement?

​

Yes. Settlement agreements are voluntary. You cannot normally be forced to accept one.

​

Will I receive a job reference?

​

Many settlement agreements include an agreed reference. The wording should be negotiated before the agreement is signed.

​

What happens if my employer breaches the agreement?

​

You may be able to bring a breach of contract claim to enforce the agreement or recover financial losses.

​

Can I make an Employment Tribunal claim after signing?

​

Usually not for the specific claims identified in the agreement. This is why obtaining independent legal advice before signing is essential.

​

How long does the settlement agreement process take?

​

Straightforward matters are often completed within one to three weeks, although complex negotiations may take longer.

​

Should I accept the first settlement offer?

​

Not necessarily. A solicitor can assess whether the proposed compensation accurately reflects your legal rights and whether better terms can be negotiated.